Study shows how employees deal with horrible bosses 

post-title

These are the measures that employees take to cope with toxic work environments. 

A study has found that, in order to cope with destructive leadership, employees resort to distancing themselves from the situation by avoiding interactions with their managers while at work. They may also resign, ignore the problem by pretending it doesn’t exist, or “shut off” emotionally. 

The study was done by consulting psychologist Dr Beatrix Brink, who obtained her doctorate in psychology at Stellenbosch and sought to explore the measures that employees take to cope in toxic work environments. 

Beatrix interviewed employees, mostly women, in the manufacturing, retail, financial services, community services and public sector. She asked them to complete the Psychological Capital Questionnaire which focuses on the individual’s ability to harness psychological resources such as hope, efficacy, resilience and optimism.

In addition to the aforementioned behaviours, Beatrix says employees’ coping mechanisms could be both positive, such as driving them to exercises, and negative, manifesting in habitual overeating, for example. 

“(Some) tried to find solace in religion or spirituality; sought social and family support which included confiding in friends and family; resorted to professional services, such as seeing a psychologist and asking assistance from their organisation’s human resource, mentoring and wellness services; and attempted to re-direct their thinking by looking for anything positive they could take away from the experience,” says Beatrix.

[chro-cta slug=a-look-at-the-2019-chro-awards]

“With varying degrees of success, they tried to stop the downward spiral of feeling overwhelmed and powerless. They did this by asserting themselves and seeking pathways to circumvent the effects of the manager’s destructive behaviour. They also tried to equip themselves with knowledge by seeking information on coping with destructive leader behaviour.”

One thing that was consistent among most respondents was that the toxic environment they operated in invariably led to employees experiencing self-doubt and questioning the skills and abilities they previously held in high regard.

“They became fearful and demotivated, experiencing emotions ranging from feeling stupid, tearful to anger. They became preoccupied with the experience and struggled to concentrate. They stopped doing the things that gave them joy and some even started to mirror the manager’s negative behaviour in their personal relationships.”

Related articles

Talent becomes a test of execution, not intent

Something is shifting in how organisations think about talent. It is no longer just about filling roles, but getting the right blend of skills needed to deliver real impact.

Succession planning is the cure for brain drain

As global migration patterns continue to shape the world of work, HR professionals must prepare for the impact of brain drain on succession planning, said Michele Simpson-Crew, managing partner of academy at Busec Nova, at the 2025 HR Indaba.

HR leaders need to strengthen youth talent pipelines

As South Africa reflects on the sacrifices of past generations this Youth Month, Madelein du Plessis, head of HR for Bayer in sub-Saharan Africa, Lyndy van den Barselaar, MD of ManpowerGroup South Africa, and Anton Visser, COO of SA Business School & Alefbet Learning, stress the need to also focus on coordinated action to rebuild a sustainable youth talent pipeline.

Top