If one resignation could disrupt your business, your succession plan is not strong enough

post-title

Lisete Harris, business leader for Marsh workforce and rewards in Africa, explores why succession planning must go further, with greater emphasis on workforce resilience, critical skills and reducing key-person dependencies.

She explains that succession planning is often treated as an HR process focused on identifying who will step into a leadership role when someone leaves. However, when an organisation relies too heavily on a handful of key people, their departure can have consequences that extend far beyond leaving a position vacant.

“Succession planning is not only a talent or HR process. It is a workforce resilience issue: the organisation is exposed when its ability to deliver strategy, manage risk, retain critical knowledge, or meet stakeholder obligations depends too heavily on a small number of people.”

Don’t put all your talent in one basket

Without effective succession planning, organisations can face a range of risks that affect their people, operations and long-term stability. Lisete outlines the potential consequences.

“Organisations could lose critical skills, relationships, and institutional knowledge. It can create inequities when emergency promotions or retention awards are made under pressure, damage employee engagement when career mobility is limited or advancement decisions lack transparency, and cause high-potential talent to leave when development promises do not translate into opportunities.”

“It also reinforces key-person dependency and talent hoarding, disrupts business when critical decision-makers or specialists leave, and slows responses to crises, major client issues, cyber events, regulatory matters or market disruptions. Other risks include losing client confidence and relationship continuity, control, governance, compliance or conduct failures, and concentrating too much knowledge or authority in one individual, ultimately increasing operational, reputational, financial and people risks.”

She notes that the risks can also affect organisational culture when departing leaders take valuable knowledge, behaviours and established ways of working with them.

She also explains that leaders need to understand what the business stands to lose when a critical capability is no longer available and how quickly it can recover.

“The relevant question is not simply who replaces this person. It is what business, workforce and risk exposures arise if this capability is unavailable and how quickly we can restore it. An uncomfortable conversation is often about key-person dependency. Are we protecting this individual because they are genuinely irreplaceable, or because we have failed to build the capability around them?”

“This can be particularly sensitive when the person is a senior leader, major client relationship holder, technical expert or high biller. The organisation may be reluctant to discuss replacement because it appears disloyal or could affect retention.”

“A second difficult conversation is whether the organisation’s reward model is unintentionally encouraging people to remain indispensable. If an expert gains status, pay, influence or client ownership by holding knowledge tightly, succession risk becomes economically reinforced.”

Succession without the guesswork

According to Lisete, a healthy succession pipeline combines talent visibility, workforce capacity and risk controls. She says it is characterised by:

- A clear inventory of roles and capabilities that are critical to business continuity.

- Risk-based segmentation rather than treating every senior role as equally important.

- Ready-now, near-term, and longer-term successor options.

- Named interim coverage for roles where a permanent successor is not yet ready.

- Development through client exposure, stretch assignments, crisis leadership, rotations, and acting

roles.

- Rewards that support mobility, knowledge transfer, and leadership development.

- Transparent criteria for potential, readiness, and progression.

- Regular review of retention risk, diversity, pay positioning, and market scarcity.

- Documented handover arrangements for key relationships, decisions, authorities, and knowledge.

- Board and executive visibility for the highest-consequence gaps.

However, having a succession plan does not necessarily mean an organisation is prepared. Lisete warns that plans can create a false sense of security when readiness has not been assessed, development commitments are not followed through or critical roles have no interim cover.

“Warning signs include succession plans that are lists of names without readiness evidence; one person appearing as successor for multiple critical roles; ‘not ready’ being used repeatedly without a development action or deadline; critical roles having no interim cover or documented handover; leaders hoarding high performers because moving them would affect current results; the organisation relying heavily on long-serving individuals with little knowledge transfer; reward outcomes favouring incumbency and individual heroics over capability building; pipeline data showing limited diversity or a narrow internal talent market; and workforce planning, risk assessments and succession reviews operating separately.”

Lisete recommends using a future-capability and scenario-based approach to succession planning, rather than planning against the current job description.

“For each critical role, identify the forces likely to reshape the role, including strategic, technological, regulatory, client and operating model changes, growth strategies and automation. Separate enduring accountabilities from activities. Define a set of future capabilities, skills and leadership behaviours that will matter in multiple future scenarios. Assess candidates for adaptability, judgement, learning agility, stakeholder leadership and risk awareness. Use scenario-based development by giving candidates assignments that expose them to plausible future demands. Revisit the role profile, successor readiness and reward implications at least annually.”

“The objective is not to predict the exact future job. It is to build a pool of people who can learn, adapt and lead through ambiguity.”

The best leaders build their replacements

She highlights the importance of measuring leaders not only by their individual performance, but also by their ability to “build credible successors, transfer knowledge, develop client and stakeholder coverage, create team capacity, enable internal mobility and reduce single-person dependency”. 

Lisete says CHROs should start by addressing the organisation’s most critical succession gap, focusing on a role that has no credible ready-now successor and no tested interim-cover plan.

“Ask what skills, relationships, knowledge and capacity would be lost; what incentives, retention risks, pay disparities or mobility barriers are reinforcing the vulnerability; and what operational, financial, client, regulatory, conduct, reputational or resilience exposure would arise. Consider what can be done in the next 90 days to reduce the exposure, what capabilities and skills a future successor would need, who the two or three most credible internal candidates are, what experience or skills each is missing, and what actions will create that experience or build those skills within the next six to 12 months.”

“This is better than beginning with a board succession-progress redesign. It turns succession from an HR exercise into a visible business-risk intervention. Once the organisation demonstrates that it can reduce exposure in one critical role, the discipline can be extended across the rest of the organisation.”

She says the ultimate test is whether an organisation would be surprised or merely inconvenienced by the unexpected departure of a critical leader.

To help organisations put this approach into practice, Lisete explains how Marsh supports businesses in identifying critical roles, assessing talent and building stronger succession pipelines through its ‘talent to impact’ approach and Lighthouse assessment platform.

“It is important to separate critical roles from critical incumbents. Marsh’s ‘talent to impact’ approach robustly identifies and quantifies roles and people which drive exponential value across your organisation. It looks at both impact-based and skill-based criteria.”

“Marsh’s Lighthouse platform is our integrated talent assessment platform, enabling clients to make evidence-based decisions across the employee lifecycle. Lighthouse hosts some of the leading assessment tools and progressive technology to meet your existing assessment practice and make room for greater impact.”

“Multi-layered campaigns can also be conducted to address varying talent needs, enabling clients to maintain a continued pulse on talent opportunities and risks, as well as increase visibility on potential cross-functional talent initiatives. In turn, this helps seamlessly identify and build talent to strengthen talent pipelines through assessment data intelligence.”

Related articles

Explaining employment equity targets with confidence

Missing a target does not automatically mean non-compliance, but employers must show how shortfalls were assessed and addressed. This was emphasised by BEE123 representatives at the 2026 HR Indaba during a session titled EE reporting readiness: Five critical actions every employer should take, now!

HR execs warn against automating people into burnout at 2026 HR Indaba

As organisations race to adopt AI, HR leaders must ensure that the pursuit of efficiency does not come at the expense of employee wellbeing, trust and workplace culture. This was explored in-depth by Kutlwano Rawana, group HR executive at the Mustek Group, and Themba Chakela, head of people, culture and change at e-Motion Consulting.

AI is reshaping workforce planning and headcount decisions

Rendani Baumgartner, managing director at RB Advisory Partners, says the biggest mistake companies can make with AI is adopting it simply because everyone else is. Before deciding what work to automate, she believes leaders need to first understand the problem they are trying to solve.

Preparing the modern workforce: What AI-ready HR really looks like

AI can take repetitive work off HR’s plate, freeing the people function to focus more of its time and expertise where it matters most. According to Paolo Urzi, partner development manager for the SADC region at Factorial, that is the most useful AI conversation for HR leaders.

Top